What type of bees do you like best?

Beekeeping & Apiculture Forum

Help Support Beekeeping & Apiculture Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.

What tyep of bees do you like?

  • Italian

    Votes: 13 7.3%
  • Carniolan

    Votes: 33 18.4%
  • Russian

    Votes: 4 2.2%
  • Other

    Votes: 129 72.1%

  • Total voters
    179

Bee View Farm

New Bee
Joined
Dec 28, 2012
Messages
24
Reaction score
0
Location
Wisconsin USA
Hive Type
Langstroth
Number of Hives
12+
I have Italions.

Are Carniolan better? I know a beekeeper who has Russians, he really likes them.
 
Last edited:
:hairpull:

Cheap bees from Greece.
Pray for them, not sure they will overwinter.
Luckily winter seems mild this year.

I do not like tham, I do not use them, but overwintering is NOT one of their problems. They do that just fine even up here in Scotland. Have used them in the past. Low productivity was their fault here, relative to colony size and feed bill.
 
Well at my place are all carniolans ( autochthonous). Except some "wise guys" introduce some italian ( but our winters kill them - lot of food consumption). Carniolans are rational with food, always brood stop at winter.
 
Indeed, if you feed them enough they will manage to overwinter. Most bees will overwinter if you give them loads of feeding.

That was not the point. Even they could get enough for their own needs and could survive perfectly well in a zero feeding situation if you never disturbed the bottom two boxes.

BUT

Given lots of space they were deceptive, because at end of season the bottom box was often completely empty and the second box lighter than we would like. We take away as much of the honey as we can.....even from the black bees which tend to be heavy in the bottoms...............and add several bars of foundation into the nest in September. Anything with cecropia in it that we have tried has been unsuitable in that respect. Thus EVERYTHING needs a winter feed here, irrespective of race.

When a colony gets to 5 deeps high on the flow, and the season comes to an end, and box 4 was being worked wall to wall before you added no5, you kind of expect a decent return out of it (we are talkng deep boxes here, at the heather). The returns are always dissappointing with this type of bee (in our environment) compared to others alongside, as the hives are very light low down and could easily have put everything into a 3 box stack. They are not a disaster, but just not as productive at the end of the day than other strains and races (not ALL races).

We are not actually interested in bees that are just 'good survivors' as this is a managed situation, but have leaned from direct experience that cecropia aint a suitable bee for us................ditto ligustica (worst), and macedonica. Caucasians bring other issues including slow build up at OSR time and a tendency to collapse with viruses in late winter. (This has been the case throughout the experience of both myself and my father, back to the 1950s and has not changed.) Other types do just fine.

A lot of people further south than us have excellent experience with cecropia however, so the label 'cheap Greek bees' is not fair. If the bee suits you you could just as easily say 'overpriced French/British' queens.

The price of queens is more a reflection of the economics of the source rather than the worth of the bees. If queen breeding is as easy as falling off a log, and the wages are not too high, and the exchange rate is favourable, then the queens tend to be cheap. If on the other hand it is difficult, or in a high wage and exchange rate area, then like for like, they will be expensive. All this before you throw in specialist knowledge and techniques for developing strains (of which we have a couple of real experts on the forum). It is perfectly possible to get good bees for a reasonable amount of money. Knowing where is another matter altogether.
 
:hairpull:

Cheap bees from Greece.
Pray for them, not sure they will overwinter.
Luckily winter seems mild this year.

I have had them 3 years now, swarmed second year but nothing this year, fills a 14x12 brood box and managed to get 60+ pounds of honey despite the bad summer out doing my other colonies, checked on them last week doing fine
 
boo-bees! :rolleyes:

I like different strains.

In good weather, my orangey coloured bees from Cornwall (and their decendants) go like dynamite. Suffer badly with Varroa.

My Carnies are good in spring, but do less well in hot weather, and swarm t the drop of a hat. Have low mite drops.

This year, only (some of) my dark varients performed extremely well (derived from swarms), but have a number of negative traits. Many have very low mite drops, with a couple of hives I have never seen a mite.

By having more than one type, I hedge my bets.... also, I enjoy having hives with different 'personalities'
 
.
You are speaking about races but every race has numerous strains. Italians is the most popular and propably it has most varietes or strains.

In Finland Italian survives on Artic Circle outdoors in insulated hives.
From NZ brought Italians will die here all. They must stop brood rearing in time here even if weathers are good.

When I bye new queens, I do not know what I get. It will be seen then. What sellers tell about their bees, It is advertizing.

One year I have 5 different strains. When they were mixed, the result was quite horrible. Their natural instincts returned.
 
Last edited:
.

One year I have 5 different strains. When they were mixed, the result was quite horrible. Their natural instincts returned.

What sort of natural instincts did they suffer with?
 
What sort of natural instincts did they suffer with?
Swarming (= reproduction) and protecting their hives (stings)

I suffered, not bees



Because these features are very important in nature to survive. Calm and non swarming are non natural features made by human. They are gene errors. With remote crossings errors will be healed.

.so I think...
.

And ferals... I no not want unselected strains into my yard...

It is hard work to keep production level over average. Free crossings and non selection brings genepool fast to average.
Capacity of laying is a key factor. In nature a good laying is not a advantage because 5 box hive cavities are rare.


To get something good from chimneys hives.........forget it.

A 500 hive beekeeper is better bee breeder than chimney

.

.

-
 
Last edited:
I don't know what kind mine are - the queen came from Cyprus they're fairly pale and very calm. I love all bees, especially like watching big fat bumble bees bumbling about.
 

Latest posts

Back
Top