"Winter Settings" - NOT !! (re BeeCraft)

Beekeeping & Apiculture Forum

Help Support Beekeeping & Apiculture Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.

itma

Queen Bee
Joined
Jul 26, 2011
Messages
8,017
Reaction score
6
Location
Kent, England
Hive Type
14x12
The October edition of Beecraft carries the suggestion of putting hives onto "Winter Settings - This term is not in any of the books".
{Beginners Corner - bottom of page 27, photo at the top}


The suggestion is a bad one that I would caution against. (Maybe that's why you won't find it in any of the books …)


Worse than just leaving crownboard holes open all winter, the author is additionally encouraging the deliberate leaving of an eke under the crownboard - from now for the whole winter.

While the Ivy flow lasts, there's a good chance they'll build comb in there. (Hard work, wasted.)
Over winter, the excess volume above the frames will ensure that the bees are cold, and having to consume stores at a needlessly high rate.

Allowing such nonsense into guidance for beginners - along with the unhelpful suggestion that it simplifies lifting the coverboard to check the bees during the winter - looks like a sad failure of editorial discipline.


A clear (no-hole) coverboard, with beespace beneath, will allow you to check the bees without removing it and opening the hive, while its seal (and insulation above) will keep the bees much more comfortable (and so not having to work so hard to survive.)
 
not so much the authors... it's the editors who set the standard for a publication.
 
They are just trying to reinvent the wheel to maintain reader interest..

Our colonies will/are behaving exactly as they did last year and the Met office can't do better than next week's weather.

- it must be a real challenge to not just republish last year's content!
 
They are just trying to reinvent the wheel to maintain reader interest..

what? this one?

HUMMER-with-Wooden-Wheels-1.jpg
 
The October edition of Beecraft carries the suggestion of putting hives onto "Winter Settings - This term is not in any of the books".
{Beginners Corner - bottom of page 27, photo at the top}


The suggestion is a bad one that I would caution against. (Maybe that's why you won't find it in any of the books …)


Worse than just leaving crownboard holes open all winter, the author is additionally encouraging the deliberate leaving of an eke under the crownboard - from now for the whole winter.

While the Ivy flow lasts, there's a good chance they'll build comb in there. (Hard work, wasted.)
Over winter, the excess volume above the frames will ensure that the bees are cold, and having to consume stores at a needlessly high rate.

Allowing such nonsense into guidance for beginners - along with the unhelpful suggestion that it simplifies lifting the coverboard to check the bees during the winter - looks like a sad failure of editorial discipline.


A clear (no-hole) coverboard, with beespace beneath, will allow you to check the bees without removing it and opening the hive, while its seal (and insulation above) will keep the bees much more comfortable (and so not having to work so hard to survive.)

Agree,
I had eke"s on my five hives treating with apiguard. Two out of the five colony's built comb in them. What a mess trying to remove.
Half a 30 lb bucket full. Currently feeding it back to them.
 

Latest posts

Back
Top